Caitlin's life is turned upside-down when she meets not one, but two perfect guys. Handsome Vince seems like the ideal catch: tall, dark, and seriously cool, a young George Clooney in perfectly tailored packaging. But then there's sweet Blake, the incurable romantic and impoverished artist with floppy bangs, British charm and puppy dog eyes. Both are falling for Caitlin, and either would be an ideal boyfriend. The choice is impossible! So Caitlin decides to take Jonesy's advice and date both guys - until things go from romantic to frantic! Meanwhile, Jude discovers a crusty old memento from his days at 'Stick It' and decides to swap it online, with unexpected results. And Wyatt nearly loses it when he's forced to work with an incredibly annoying retired couple he nicknames 'the Bickersons'.