Optometrist Sarah has help from her childhood friend Daniel to fix up her clinic. With interest he follows Sarah's dating life as she tries to date two different guys, Adam and Tom, at the same time as her ex-husband, Nigel, returns into the picture with signs of regretting the divorce. With Hanukkah coming up she starts to receive a perfect gifts for each of the eight days before the celebration. But who is it that sends these mysterious gifts? Which of her suitors knows her so well?